You are selling a car, a phone or a sofa, and the buyer sends "proof of transfer" so they can leave with the item right away. It is one of the most common scams between private sellers and buyers, and it rests on one simple confusion: a payment proof is not money in your account.
The document the buyer shows you, a screenshot or a PDF, comes out of their own banking app. At best it proves a transfer order was entered. A scheduled or deferred transfer can still be cancelled before it runs, and a proof can be edited, or made up from scratch, in a few minutes.
The only proof of payment is the credit on your account, seen by you.
The most common scenarios
The "transfer sent" screenshot, sent when collecting the item, with an excuse for the delay: "it takes two or three days".
The fake email from a bank or a payment service, announcing funds "pending validation" until you send a tracking number or pay a fee.
The overpayment: the buyer claims to have sent more than the price and asks you to refund the difference.
The "receive your payment" link leading to a fake page of your bank that asks for your login or card details.
The one check that counts
Open your bank's app or website yourself, never from a link you received.
Check that the transaction appears as a credit on your account and that the balance went up.
Suggest an instant transfer: a buyer acting in good faith can pay in seconds, in front of you.
Until the money is in your account, the item does not leave, whatever the urgency.
Signs of forgery on the document
They confirm a doubt; they never replace checking your account:
The payee IBAN is not exactly yours, or it is cut short where it should appear in full.
The amount or the name is in a slightly different font, misaligned, or laid on a background that does not match.
The date and time do not fit your conversation, or a regular transfer is shown as "executed" on a Sunday, when such transfers are normally processed on business days.
The PDF was produced by a PDF editor or an online converter, not by a bank's website (how to tell).
What Verification of Payee changes
Since 9 October 2025, the payer's bank checks, before every euro transfer, that the name entered matches the IBAN's holder. That protects whoever sends the money against a mistake or fake bank details. It does not protect the seller against a fake proof: again, only your account counts.
If you have been scammed
Keep everything: the ad, the messages, the proof you received, the buyer's details, the tracking number if the item was shipped.
Report the buyer's account to the listings platform.
File a police report. In France, a complaint about an online scam can be filed online (the THESEE platform, reached from service-public.fr).
If you typed your bank login or card details on a fake page, call your bank at once.
Frequently asked questions
Is a screenshot of a bank transfer proof of payment?
No. It comes out of the buyer's app and can be edited or made up in minutes. The only proof is the credit showing on your own account.
How can I be sure a bank transfer has arrived?
Open your bank's app yourself, not through a link you received, and check that the transaction appears as a credit on your account. An instant transfer arrives in seconds.
Can a transfer be cancelled after the proof was sent?
Yes, if it was scheduled or deferred: it can be cancelled until it runs. An instant transfer, on the other hand, is final within seconds.